Log in

No account? Create an account
Errantry: Novak's Journal
...Words to cast/My feelings into sculpted thoughts/To make some wisdom last
Theological Notebook: Dissertation Documentation; Following the Rise of the Third Reich 
30th-Apr-2009 07:31 am
Indy Says Study History
Up early/late working on the dissertation, bogged down in trying to work out exactly how much documentation I might need for a section I'm working on, or how much I can simply write from observation in making a generalization. I'm thinking and writing right now about the extent to which I think the Catholic Charismatic Renewal has either lost steam since the 1970s/80s or has become somewhat marginalized in the life of the Catholic Church as a whole, at least in the North American/European parts of the Church. Obviously, given my dissertation topic, I think that there's a great deal of potential in the Renewal or in a spirituality and ecclesiology organized around the idea of charisms. Yet at the same time, I think that there have been inadvertent cultural imports from American Pentecostalism that might have hampered the movement's Catholicity, and at times the divisive tendency to become a "church within a church" that undermines the unity in diversity that is intrinsic to Catholicism. So I'm trying to figure out the extent to which I have to document/prove such observations beyond just an appeal to my own experience or to invoke such observations as (alleged) commonplaces. It's a pain in the butt to read my own writing as though I were a scholar critiquing it, but it's the only way to save myself grief in the end, lest I get too glib or assume too much.

Yawn. The fog here in Milwaukee was as thick this morning as I've ever seen it, hiding even the bulk of the McCormick dorm across the street from me, but it has been clearing dramatically in the last fifteen minutes. Thought I ought to share that.

Utterly unrelated to my dissertation, my current free reading has me quite riveted over meals or during breaks. I was struck by some of Thomas Merton's comments in his journal as he was reading the American foreign correspondent William L. Shirer's The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich: A History of Nazi Germany, which won the National Book Award back in 1961, as well as by Merton's scathing poem "Chant to be used in Processions around a site with Furnaces" and his sobering essay "A Devout Meditation in Memory of Adolf Eichmann" from Raids on the Unspeakable, which was part of my Lenten reading this year. So I picked up the massive Rise and Fall, and it's utterly captivating in its horror.

I had picked up a lot of this history over the years, but I've never read such an extended account of the rise of Nazism. I'm amazed by the power of one man – no matter the extent of his talent for public speaking and his skill for organization – to so bewitch a people. I am particularly amazed at the irony of being able to so effectively sell an entire nation the ideology that they are a Master Race while at the same time you utterly enslave and defile them. Or worse, persuade them to defile themselves. I find myself wondering whether that ever occurred to Hitler – who, if he believed in anything, believed in "racial" concepts of humanity and in the utter racial superiority of his German "Aryans" – and yet at the same time so distrusted, abused, terrified and degraded the entire German people, creating in them a far more slavish mentality than in those people the Nazis conquered militarily. I cannot think of any greater argument against his ideas of a racial superiority than the utter debasement to which he reduced his people. Yet I imagine that in his lust for control and in his dreams of conquest, he never could see the extent to which he was even his own evil ideology's worst nightmare.
30th-Apr-2009 04:59 pm (UTC) - Hilter
I recently bought a used book titled "Germany, Hitler & World II by Gerhard L. Weinberg-someday I like to read it-Hitler is someone I like to read about-the book by Weinberg might be something to look at-I also bought recently a used book titled "The Dark Valley: A Panorama of the 1930's" by Piers Brendon-there is a chapter in this book titled 'The Triumph of Hitler'.

1st-May-2009 12:31 am (UTC) - Re: Hilter
I can understand why so many people do research into the subject: there's a horrible fascination to it, like reading The Lord of the Flies for the first time, in realizing that these are real people, in a real situation not all that removed from our own. That's why I think Merton's "Devout Meditation in Memory of Adolf Eichmann" is so important: that we cannot excuse ourselves by writing these people off as insane. The fact that these people were perfectly sane – that they just believed crazy things – is the greatest of political and ethical warnings; for people after World War II to not engage in that kind of self-scrutiny of our own politics and presuppositions is to invite the same kind of thing to happen again.
This page was loaded Apr 25th 2019, 2:48 pm GMT.