Log in

No account? Create an account
Errantry: Novak's Journal
...Words to cast/My feelings into sculpted thoughts/To make some wisdom last
Random: Card drawing on L'Engle? 
29th-Aug-2006 05:52 pm
Loyola Faculty Portrait
I just noticed a startling parallel between two books, making me wonder to what extent Orson Scott Card in his 1986 Hugo and and Nebula Award-winning Speaker For The Dead might have borrowed from Madeleine L'Engle's 1973 A Wind In The Door.

In Card's book, the key plot – again, I'm totally spoiling the surprise if you read further – comes from discovering that the alien species being observed is in fact a juvenile form of the species, which has to die in order to transform from a mammal to the adult form of a telepathic tree. It's a killer surprise in the story, incredibly alien to our perspectives, and a persistent mystery throughout the text, where the humans think that the species displays strange violence, murdering their own and planting a tree in the remains, and then acting as though nothing odd had happened. So I was surprised upon just re-reading L'Engle's A Wind In The Door, a "companion book" more than a "sequel" to her Newberry Medal-winning classic A Wrinkle In Time, and discovering essentially the same device, which I had long ago forgotten, and took to be utterly original when I read Card a few years ago. I've been looking online to see if anyone else has drawn out this parallel, but no luck as yet. Has anyone else here ever noticed this?
30th-Aug-2006 01:39 am (UTC)
Speaker for the Dead is one of my favorite books of all time. I have never read any L'Engle, however. I will put it on my books to read list.
This page was loaded Jan 20th 2019, 8:00 am GMT.